Sivavakkiyar Siddhar: The Rebel Poet of the Siddhars

By Yoga Kudil

Sivavakkiyar Siddhar is a Tamil Siddhar poet famous for his fearless verses against empty ritual, idol worship and caste, and for his insistence that God lives within the human being. His collection of songs is called the Sivavakkiyam, and he is often described as the boldest voice in all Siddhar literature.

Who was Sivavakkiyar?

Very little is known for certain. His name means “he of the utterance of Shiva”, and one legend says he was born with the name of Shiva on his lips. Other stories about his family, his guru and his marriage circulate in popular books, but they differ from one another and cannot be verified.

His date is also uncertain. Some scholars place him as early as about the ninth or tenth century, which would make him one of the earliest Siddhar poets after Thirumoolar; others put him later. He appears in some lists of the 18 Siddhars and not in others.

One tradition, held especially among Vaishnavas, identifies him with Thirumazhisai Alvar, one of the twelve Alvar saints, and says he was a Saiva who later became a devotee of Vishnu. Scholars generally doubt this identification. It may have arisen because the Sivavakkiyam praises the name of Rama as well as that of Shiva, and because both poets share a blunt, questioning manner.

What is the Sivavakkiyam?

The Sivavakkiyam is a collection of a little over five hundred verses, the exact number varying between editions. The verses are in a strong, drumming rhythm and in language close to everyday speech. Many end with a challenge or a rhetorical question thrown at the listener.

The content ranges widely. There are verses of sharp social criticism, verses on yoga and breath, verses on the sacred five-syllable mantra of Shiva, and verses of plain devotion. It is not a systematic work, and it is possible that verses by other hands were added to it over time.

What did Sivavakkiyar say about idol worship?

His most quoted verse addresses a worshipper who sets up a stone, calls it God, offers a few flowers and walks around it murmuring mantras. Will the planted stone speak, the poet asks, when the Lord is within you? Does the cooking pot or the ladle know the taste of the curry? The verse is given here in paraphrase, but the two images, the stone and the ladle, are his own.

In the same spirit he questions temple-going, sacred baths, ritual purity and the recitation of scripture without understanding. His point is not that God is absent but that God is nearer than any of these things. The body is the temple, and the search must be made inside.

It is fair to add that this is one voice within the Tamil tradition, not the whole of it. The Nayanmars and countless devotees have found the divine through temple worship and image, and Tamil Saivism has room for both paths. Sivavakkiyar’s target is worship that has become mechanical.

Sivavakkiyar on caste

His verses on caste are just as direct. He asks, in essence, what makes one woman high-born and another low-born: is there any mark on flesh, skin or bone to tell them apart? Birth, he says, is the same for all, and so is the body. For verses composed many centuries ago, these lines are remarkably plain, and they are part of the reason the Siddhars were long regarded with suspicion by the orthodox and with affection by ordinary people.

Was Sivavakkiyar an atheist?

No, although he is sometimes quoted as if he were. His criticism comes from within faith. The same collection that mocks the planted stone also sings of the bliss of knowing Shiva within, praises the divine name and speaks of yogic practice as the way to that knowledge. What he rejects is the idea that God can be confined to a place, a caste or a ceremony. In this he stands squarely in the Siddhar tradition, which values direct experience over inherited form.

Why read him today?

Sivavakkiyar is worth reading because he is hard to be comfortable with. He does not let the religious person hide behind observance, and he does not let the sceptic dismiss the inner life either. His questions are simple enough for a child and difficult enough for a lifetime: where are you looking for God, and why there?