Does God Exist? The Main Arguments, Fairly Put

By Yoga Kudil

Does God exist? Nobody has proved it either way to the satisfaction of all thoughtful people. There are serious arguments for the existence of God, serious arguments against, and a third response from the contemplative traditions, which say the question cannot be settled by argument at all but only by looking within. This article sets out all three as fairly as it can and does not pretend to close the matter.

The main arguments for God

The argument from existence. Everything we know of depends on something else for its existence. Why is there a universe at all, and not nothing? Believers argue that the chain of causes must rest on something that exists by its own nature, and this is what is meant by God.

The argument from order. The universe follows precise laws, and life seems to depend on physical conditions falling within narrow ranges. To many this suggests intelligence behind it.

The moral argument. Human beings feel that some things are truly right or wrong, not merely useful or fashionable. Some argue that this makes best sense if goodness has a source beyond human opinion.

The argument from experience. In every age and culture, people have reported direct experience of a divine presence. Believers ask whether all of them can be mistaken.

The main arguments against

The problem of suffering. If God is all-powerful and all-good, why do children suffer, and why do earthquakes and disease strike without regard to merit? This is the oldest and strongest objection, and believers themselves feel its weight. Indian traditions answer partly through karma, but that answer also raises questions.

Lack of evidence. God cannot be observed or tested. Sceptics hold that a claim without evidence need not be accepted, and that the burden lies with the one who makes the claim.

Natural explanations. Science explains much that was once credited to gods, from lightning to the variety of living things.

Between belief and denial stands the agnostic, who says honestly, “I do not know,” and sometimes adds that it may not be knowable.

Indian thought was never of one mind

It is sometimes assumed that Indian philosophy simply takes God for granted. It does not. The Nyaya school constructed careful logical arguments for a creator. The early Samkhya and Mimamsa schools, though they accept the Vedas, saw no need for a creator God. Buddhism and Jainism reject a creator while teaching liberation. The Charvaka materialists denied God, the soul and the afterlife altogether. Advaita Vedanta speaks of Brahman, an absolute reality that is not a person at all, while Saiva Siddhanta and the Vaishnava schools affirm a personal Lord who bestows grace.

Even the Rig Veda holds the question open. Its hymn of creation (10.129) wonders where creation came from and ends by saying that the one who looks down from the highest heaven surely knows, or perhaps even he does not.

What do the contemplatives say?

Saints and mystics rarely try to prove God. They say, in effect: do not believe us, look for yourself. Their claim is that God is not one more object in the universe, to be found or not found like a distant planet, but the ground of the awareness with which you are reading this. On this view the question “Does God exist?” turns into another: “What am I?”

Thirumoolar’s Thirumanthiram says that the heart is the great temple and the body of flesh its shrine. The Siddhar poet Sivavakkiyar mocked outward ritual and pointed to the Lord within. Our articles on who is God and where is God follow these ideas further.

This is not a proof either. An inner experience convinces the one who has it and nobody else, and a sceptic may fairly say so. What the contemplatives offer is an experiment, not a conclusion.

Living with the question

Three honest positions are open: belief, disbelief, and not knowing. Each has been held by wise and decent people. What the traditions on all sides tend to agree on is how to hold your position: without contempt for those who differ, without claiming more certainty than you have, and with your conduct in good order.

For many people the question is not answered once but lived with, and it often changes shape with age and experience. It may begin as “Is there a God up there?” and become, in time, a search for what is real within oneself.