Who Is God? How the Great Traditions Answer

By Yoga Kudil

Who is God? In the widest sense, God is the supreme reality that people in nearly every culture have held to be the source and ground of all that exists. Beyond that, the answers differ. Some traditions describe God as a person who creates, knows and loves. Others describe an absolute beyond all personality. Many Indian teachers say God is both: formless in essence, and taking form out of compassion for those who seek.

The personal God

Judaism, Christianity and Islam teach one God who created the universe, is distinct from it, and relates to human beings as lord, judge and merciful guardian. Sikhism likewise teaches one formless, timeless creator. In these faiths God is addressed as “You”. Prayer is a conversation, and the proper human response is worship, trust and obedience.

Hindu devotional traditions share much of this. For a Vaishnava, God is Vishnu, known through Rama and Krishna. For a Saiva, God is Shiva. For a Shakta, the supreme is the Goddess. Each tradition holds its chosen form to be the highest, and many Hindus also accept that the one God answers to all these names.

The God beyond form

The Upanishads speak of Brahman: infinite, without form or qualities, not a being among beings but being itself. Asked to describe it, the sages often answered neti, neti, “not this, not this”, because anything that can be pointed to is less than the whole.

Hindu thought holds the two views together with a pair of terms. Nirguna Brahman is the absolute without attributes. Saguna Brahman, or Ishvara, is the same reality seen with attributes, as the Lord who can be loved and prayed to.

It is worth adding that not every tradition has a God in this sense. Buddhism and Jainism teach paths to liberation without a creator.

How the Hindu schools differ

The schools disagree on how God, the soul and the world are related, and the disagreements are real.

Advaita, taught by Shankara, holds that Brahman alone is ultimately real and that the individual self is, in truth, not different from it.

Vishishtadvaita, taught by Ramanuja, holds that souls and the world are real and are related to God as a body is to its soul.

Dvaita, taught by Madhva, holds that God and the soul are eternally distinct.

Saiva Siddhanta, the main philosophy of Tamil Saivism, speaks of three eternal realities: the Lord (pati), the soul (pasu) and the bond (pasam). The soul is freed by Shiva’s grace and is united with him, yet is not simply identical with him.

What does the Tamil tradition say?

The common Tamil word for God, kadavul, is often explained as kada plus ul: that which goes beyond everything and is within everything.

The Thirukkural opens with a chapter in praise of God, and its first couplet says that as the letter A is the first of all letters, so the primal Lord is first in the world. Thiruvalluvar names no sect and no deity. His God is described by qualities: pure knowledge, freedom from desire and aversion, a refuge for the mind.

Thirumoolar gives two of the most quoted lines in Tamil spirituality. One is ondre kulam, oruvane devan: humanity is one family and God is one. The other says that the ignorant think love and Shiva are two things, while those who know see that love itself is Shiva.

Can God be known?

Nearly all traditions say that God cannot be grasped by the intellect in the way an object is grasped. They differ on what is possible instead. Devotional schools say God is known through love and surrender, and reveals himself by grace. The path of knowledge says God is realised when one discovers what one’s own self truly is. Many teachers treat these as two roads up the same hill.

A fair summary would be this. Asked who God is, the traditions reply with a name, a form, a philosophy, or silence, depending on who is asking. And many of them add that the question is finally answered not by a definition but by a change in the one who asks. Whether there is a God at all is a separate matter, which we take up in does God exist.