God's Will: What It Means and Where Effort Fits

By Yoga Kudil

God’s will is the belief that what happens in the world, and what human beings ought to do in it, rests finally on the intention of God. The phrase is used in two senses that are easy to confuse. One is what God brings about: events, outcomes, the course of a life. The other is what God asks of us: right conduct. Most traditions hold both, and most of the difficulty with the idea comes from mixing them up.

This page looks at the meaning of the term across traditions and its relation to effort. The more personal question, how to trust when life goes badly, is taken up in God’s plan.

What does God’s will mean in different traditions?

In Christianity the central texts are two prayers of Jesus: “Thy will be done” in the Lord’s Prayer (Matthew 6:10), and “not my will, but thine, be done” in the garden before his arrest (Luke 22:42).

In Islam, whose name itself means submission to God, believers add insha’Allah, “if God wills”, when speaking of the future, and belief in the divine decree is counted among the articles of faith. A related virtue is tawakkul, reliance on God.

Sikh scripture speaks of hukam, the divine order. The Japji opens by asking how one becomes truthful and answers, in essence: by walking in accordance with that order.

Hindu traditions vary. The Bhagavad Gita says the Lord dwells in the hearts of all beings and moves them (18.61), and Krishna tells Arjuna to be “merely an instrument” (11.33). Yet most Hindu schools also say God gives results according to each soul’s own karma, so God’s will is not arbitrary: it works through a moral order, described in the law of karma.

In Tamil Saivism the word that carries the idea is arul, grace. Saiva Siddhanta teaches that all of the Lord’s acts, including those that feel harsh, are grace directed to the soul’s release. Manickavasagar puts the dependence finely in the Thiruvasagam: it is by His grace that one bows at His feet.

Buddhism and Jainism are the exceptions. Neither has a creator whose will governs events; they explain the world by karma and conditions alone.

If everything is God’s will, why make an effort?

Almost no tradition draws the conclusion that effort is pointless. They place the two side by side.

The Gita is spoken to a man who wants to stop acting, and its instruction is to act: you have a right to the work, not to its fruit (2.47). After eighteen chapters Krishna does not command; he tells Arjuna to reflect fully and then do as he chooses (18.63).

Thiruvalluvar is equally direct. Even if the result is denied by fate, he says, effort will pay the wages of one’s bodily labour (Thirukkural 619). A widely known saying attributed to the Prophet Muhammad makes the same point: tie your camel, and then trust in God.

The Saiva saint Appar, whose hymns are part of the Thevaram, divides the responsibilities in one line: His duty is to bear up even me, His servant; my duty is to keep on serving.

The common pattern: effort belongs to the human being, the outcome to God.

How can anyone know God’s will?

Here honesty is needed. No tradition claims that an ordinary person can read God’s intention in a particular event. What they offer are guides for conduct: scripture, the example of saints, the counsel of a trustworthy teacher, and a conscience kept clear by practice.

A practical rule follows. “God’s will” is something to say about what has already happened and cannot be changed. It is not a reliable guide to what one should do next, and anyone who is very sure that God wants precisely what they themselves want has reason to pause.

Misuses of the idea

Three are common. The first is laziness: “if God wills it, it will happen” used to avoid work that is plainly one’s own. The second is blaming God for the results of one’s own choices. The third, and the most serious, is using “it is God’s will” to justify harm or injustice done to others, or to tell someone to accept ill-treatment.

Understood properly, accepting God’s will is not resignation. It is doing one’s part fully and letting go of the claim to control the rest, an attitude that devotional traditions develop into the practice of surrender to God.