Good Karma: What It Is and How It Is Made
Good karma is action done with a wholesome intention, such as generosity, kindness or honesty, together with the beneficial results such action is believed to bring to the doer. Sanskrit calls it punya, merit; Tamil calls it nalvinai, “good deed”, and often simply aram, virtue. In every tradition that uses the word, what makes karma good is first of all the state of mind behind it.
What counts as good karma?
The lists in different traditions are close to one another. Early Buddhism names three bases of merit: giving, moral conduct and the cultivation of the mind. Hindu texts praise dana (giving), seva (service), truthfulness, non-injury and self-control. The Thirukkural devotes its first book to aram, with chapters on hospitality, kind speech, gratitude, fairness, giving and compassion.
In practice, this covers things such as:
- feeding the hungry and giving to those in need
- caring for parents, the old and the sick
- speaking truthfully and gently
- not harming living beings
- doing one’s own work honestly
- forgiving an injury
Compassion towards all living beings has a special place in the Tamil tradition. Its saints and poets return again and again to relieving the hunger of others as a form of worship.
Why does intention matter more than the act?
Because the same outward act can come from very different places. A donation given to be praised, to gain influence or to quiet a guilty feeling is not the same act as one given because someone is in need.
Thiruvalluvar puts it in one couplet: to be free of stain in one’s own mind is the whole of virtue; everything else is mere show (Thirukkural 34). The Bhagavad Gita describes the best kind of gift as one given because it ought to be given, to someone who can make no return, at the right place and time (17.20).
This also means good karma does not depend on money. A kind word, patience with a difficult person, or a job done properly when nobody is checking all count.
Does good karma cancel bad karma?
The common picture of a bank account, where good deeds are deposits that wipe out bad ones, is not quite how the traditions describe it. In most accounts each kind of action bears its own fruit: good results from good acts, painful results from harmful ones. This is covered in the law of karma.
What is taught is that good action can weaken the effect of past wrongs, in the way a spoonful of salt ruins a cup of water but is hardly tasted in a great river; the image comes from a Buddhist discourse. The Gita offers reassurance on this point: no one who does good, Krishna says, ever comes to a bad end (6.40).
Is good karma the final goal?
Here the traditions add something that surprises many people. Good karma is better than bad, but it still binds. Its results are pleasant and they also come to an end, and a mind that does good in order to enjoy the reward remains tied to the cycle of reward and loss. Teachers have long compared merit to a chain of gold and demerit to a chain of iron: one is more comfortable, and both are chains.
So a further step is taught. The Gita asks for action done well and without clinging to its fruit. Saiva Siddhanta speaks of reaching an evenness in which pleasant and unpleasant results are received in the same spirit, which it regards as the soul’s readiness for grace. Good deeds remain necessary, because they purify the mind and reduce selfishness. They are the road, though not the destination, which is liberation. The wider framework is in what is karma.
How to do good without keeping accounts
A few plain suggestions follow from all this. Give regularly, in whatever measure is honest for your means, and do it quietly. Choose the act in front of you over grand plans. Expect nothing back, including thanks.
And avoid using “good karma” as a trade, doing something kind in order to pass an exam or win a case. It is natural to hope, but the traditions are consistent that the deed is cleanest, and the mind lightest, when the good is done for its own sake. As the Kural says, only the happiness that comes from virtue is real happiness (Thirukkural 39).