Jnana Yoga: The Path of Knowledge and Self-Enquiry

By Yoga Kudil

Jnana yoga is the path of knowledge: the way of reaching liberation by enquiring into the nature of the self until one knows directly what one really is. Jnana (also spelt gyana, and gnanam in Tamil) means knowledge, and yoga here means a path or discipline. It is one of the main paths described in the Bhagavad Gita, alongside the paths of selfless action and devotion.

What kind of knowledge is meant?

Jnana here does not mean learning, wide reading or cleverness. The Upanishads distinguish lower knowledge, which includes every science and even the scriptures themselves, from higher knowledge, by which the imperishable is known. Jnana yoga aims at the second.

The underlying idea is that our basic problem is a mistake. We take ourselves to be the body and the changing mind, and so we fear, crave and suffer. If the problem is ignorance, no amount of action can remove it, just as no amount of activity in a dark room produces light. Only knowing removes not-knowing. The Gita praises this strongly, saying that nothing in this world purifies like knowledge.

The four qualifications

The tradition of Advaita Vedanta lists four things a seeker needs before this enquiry can bear fruit. They work as a description of a prepared mind more than as a rulebook.

  • Viveka: discrimination between what is lasting and what is passing.
  • Vairagya: dispassion towards what is passing. See vairagya meaning.
  • The six inner disciplines: calmness of mind, control of the senses, withdrawal from distraction, forbearance, trust in the teaching and teacher, and steady focus.
  • Mumukshutva: a strong desire for liberation.

Jnana yoga has a reputation as a path for a few, and this list is the reason. Without some quietness and detachment, enquiry becomes mere argument. That is why teachers usually recommend selfless work, devotion and meditation as preparation.

The three steps: hearing, reflecting, contemplating

The classical method has three stages.

Shravana is hearing: listening to the teaching of the Upanishads from a teacher who knows it. The central message is that the self is not different from Brahman, the one reality, as discussed under atman and Brahman.

Manana is reflection: thinking the teaching through, raising every doubt and objection, and resolving them by reasoning, until the mind no longer resists.

Nididhyasana is sustained contemplation: dwelling on what has been understood until it stops being an idea and becomes one’s settled way of seeing.

One tool used throughout is negation, known by the Upanishadic phrase “neti, neti”: not this, not this. Whatever can be observed, the body, sensations, thoughts, moods, cannot be the observer. By setting aside each in turn, attention is turned back on the awareness that knows them all.

Self-enquiry: how is jnana yoga practised today?

The best-known modern form is the self-enquiry taught by Ramana Maharshi of Tiruvannamalai. In place of long study, he advised a single question held with full attention: “Who am I?” When a thought arises, one asks to whom it has arisen. The answer is “to me”. One then asks who this “me” is and looks for its source. Ramana taught that the “I” thought, when traced back in this way, subsides, and what remains is the self. His approach is described in Who Am I by Ramana Maharshi.

Anyone using intensive meditation of any kind while dealing with a mental health difficulty should seek guidance from a qualified teacher and a doctor.

Jnana in the Tamil Saiva tradition

Tamil Saiva Siddhanta also places jnana at the summit. Its four stages of practice are charya, kriya, yoga and jnana, and only the last is said to lead directly to union with Siva. Its understanding differs from Advaita in an important way. Knowledge is not something the soul achieves by its own reasoning. It is granted by Siva’s grace, often through a guru, when the soul is ripe. And the knower does not discover that it is God, but comes to know God as its inseparable Lord. The Thirumanthiram of Thirumoolar treats jnana in this spirit.

Is jnana yoga opposed to devotion?

Rarely, in practice. Shankara, the great exponent of knowledge, is credited with devotional hymns. Devotional teachers in turn say that love ends in knowledge of the beloved. The Gita presents the paths as suited to different temperaments and not as rivals. Many teachers say that devotion loosens the ego and knowledge then shows it was never the self.