Who Am I? Ramana Maharshi and Self-Enquiry Explained
“Who Am I?” by Ramana Maharshi, known in Tamil as “Nan Yar?”, is a short work that sets out his method of self-enquiry. Its teaching is that lasting happiness is our own nature, and that the direct way to find it is to turn attention to the feeling of “I” and trace it to its source. If you are looking for the wider spiritual question and how different traditions answer it, see our general article on who am I. This page is about Ramana’s text and method.
How the text came to be written
Ramana Maharshi was born in 1879 at Tiruchuli in Tamil Nadu. In 1896, as a sixteen-year-old schoolboy in Madurai, he was seized by a sudden fear of death. Instead of running from it, he lay down and asked himself what it was that dies. He came out of the experience convinced that he was not the body but the awareness within it. A few weeks later he left home for Tiruvannamalai and the hill of Arunachala, where he stayed until his death in 1950.
In his early years on the hill he rarely spoke. Around 1902 a visitor named Sivaprakasam Pillai, who had studied philosophy, came to him with questions, beginning with “Who am I?”. Ramana is said to have answered by gesture and by writing. Sivaprakasam Pillai kept the answers, and they were published some two decades later. Ramana afterwards rewrote the material as a continuous essay. The text circulates in more than one form, and a widely read version has twenty-eight questions and answers.
What does “Nan Yar?” say?
The work is only a few pages long. Its argument runs roughly as follows.
Every being wants to be happy without any sorrow, and everyone loves themselves most. Happiness is in fact the nature of the self, and it is felt daily in deep sleep, when there is no mind. To gain it, one must know oneself, and the chief means is the enquiry “Who am I?”.
Ramana then sets aside what the “I” is not: the physical body, the senses, the organs of action, the vital breaths, and even the thinking mind. What remains after all these are negated is pure awareness, and that, he says, is what I am.
He describes the mind as nothing but thoughts, and says the root of all thoughts is the thought “I”. Find where this “I” rises from, and the mind subsides.
How is self-enquiry practised?
The method is simple to state. When a thought arises, do not follow it. Ask instead, “To whom has this thought come?” The answer is “To me”. Then ask, “Who am I?” This turns the mind back towards its source, and the thought fades. Another thought will come, and the same is done again.
Ramana compares the thought “Who am I?” to the stick used to stir a funeral pyre. It burns up the other thoughts, and in the end it is burnt too. The question is not a mantra to be repeated, and it is not meant to produce a clever answer. It is a way of holding attention on the bare sense of “I”.
He treats other practices as aids. Breath control, meditation on a form and repetition of a mantra quieten the mind, he says, but the mind rises again once the practice stops. Only enquiry removes the root. He also says that complete surrender to God reaches the same end, because both give up the separate “I”. On that path, see surrender to God.
Where does his teaching stand among the traditions?
Ramana’s conclusion, that the self alone is real and is one with the ultimate reality, agrees with Advaita Vedanta, though he said he arrived at it by experience and read the scriptures only later. His language is also rooted in Tamil Saiva devotion, and he composed hymns to Arunachala as Siva.
Not every tradition accepts his conclusion. Saiva Siddhanta and the theistic schools of Vedanta hold that the soul stays distinct from God, and Buddhism denies a permanent self.
Common misunderstandings
Self-enquiry is not self-analysis. It does not ask about your personality, your past or your motives. It is also not a denial of daily life: Ramana did not ask people to leave their work or family. And it is seldom quick. The text itself expects old tendencies to keep rising, and advises a patient return to the question. The practice is a form of jnana yoga, the path of knowledge, in its simplest shape.