Atman and Brahman: How Are They Related?
Atman and Brahman are the two central ideas of the Upanishads. Atman is the innermost self of a person, and Brahman is the ultimate reality behind the whole universe. The Upanishads declare that the two are deeply connected, and some of their statements say outright that they are one. What exactly that connection is has been debated for well over a thousand years, and the three great schools of Vedanta, Advaita, Vishishtadvaita and Dvaita, give three different answers.
What do the two words mean?
Atman is the self: not the body or the personality, but the awareness that knows them. Brahman comes from a Sanskrit root meaning to grow or expand, and refers to the vast, unlimited reality from which everything arises, in which it exists and into which it returns. Brahman should not be confused with Brahma, the creator god of the Puranas.
The Upanishadic sages approached reality from two sides. Looking outward, they asked what lies behind the world, and called it Brahman. Looking inward, they asked what lies behind the mind, and called it atman. Their striking claim was that both searches arrive at the same place.
What do the Upanishads say?
Four short sentences, later called the mahavakyas or “great sayings”, are traditionally held to sum up the teaching, one from each Veda:
- Prajnanam brahma, “consciousness is Brahman” (Aitareya Upanishad)
- Aham brahmasmi, “I am Brahman” (Brihadaranyaka Upanishad)
- Tat tvam asi, “you are that” (Chandogya Upanishad)
- Ayam atma brahma, “this self is Brahman” (Mandukya Upanishad)
In the Chandogya Upanishad, the sage Uddalaka teaches his son Shvetaketu with examples. Salt dissolved in water cannot be seen, yet every drop tastes of it. In the same way, he says, the subtle essence pervades everything, “and you are that”. The Upanishads also contain passages that speak of the self and the Lord as two, which is one reason later teachers could read them differently.
How do the three schools of Vedanta differ?
Advaita, “non-dualism”, is associated with Adi Shankara, who is usually placed around the eighth century. It takes the great sayings literally: atman and Brahman are identical. There is only one reality. The appearance of many separate selves and a separate world is due to ignorance, as a rope is mistaken for a snake in dim light. Liberation is the removal of that mistake through knowledge. For more, see the meaning of Advaita.
Vishishtadvaita, “qualified non-dualism”, was set out by Ramanuja, who was born at Sriperumbudur in Tamil Nadu and is traditionally dated to the eleventh and twelfth centuries. He held that Brahman is a personal God, Vishnu, and that individual selves and the material world are real. They relate to God as a body relates to its soul: inseparable from him and wholly dependent on him, but not identical with him. Liberation comes through devotion and grace, and the liberated self lives in loving communion with God.
Dvaita, “dualism”, was taught by Madhva in thirteenth-century Karnataka. He held that the difference between God and the individual self is real and eternal. God alone is independent, and selves and matter depend on him entirely. Madhva insisted on five permanent distinctions: between God and selves, God and matter, one self and another, selves and matter, and one material thing and another. Liberation is the bliss of being in God’s presence, attained by devotion and his grace.
Put simply, Advaita says “I am That”, Vishishtadvaita says “I am a part of That”, and Dvaita says “I belong to That”.
Where does Saiva Siddhanta stand?
Saiva Siddhanta, the chief philosophy of Tamil Saivism, lies outside the Vedanta schools but faces the same question. It speaks of pati (the Lord, Siva), pasu (the soul) and pasam (the bonds). The soul is real and eternally distinct from Siva, yet in liberation it is so closely united with him that the two cannot be separated. The tradition describes this as being neither one nor two. The hymns of the Thevaram carry the same blend of intimacy and reverence.
Does the difference matter in practice?
It shapes how a person practises. One who follows Advaita leans towards enquiry and the path of knowledge. One who follows Ramanuja, Madhva or the Saiva saints leans towards worship, service and surrender. Yet all agree on the starting point: the small, anxious “I” that we usually take ourselves to be is not the full truth. All agree too that the goal, moksha, is freedom from that narrow identity.