Shaivism and Vaishnavism

Similarities and Differences

Shaivism and Vaishnavism are the two largest devotional traditions within Hinduism. Shaivism worships Shiva as the supreme being; Vaishnavism worships Vishnu, often in his forms as Rama and Krishna. They differ in their central deity, their scriptures, their symbols and parts of their philosophy, yet they share the same Vedic roots, the same ideas of karma, dharma and liberation, and the same emphasis on loving devotion. Many Hindus honour both.

This page compares them fairly. For each tradition on its own, see Shaivism and Lord Shiva.

What is the main difference between Shaivism and Vaishnavism?

The main difference is whom each tradition regards as the highest form of God. For Shaivas, Shiva is the supreme reality: creator, preserver and destroyer, beyond all forms and yet present in them, often worshipped as the linga or as Nataraja, the cosmic dancer. For Vaishnavas, Vishnu is the supreme reality, who rests on the cosmic ocean and descends into the world as avatars, such as Rama and Krishna, to restore dharma.

Each tradition usually gives the other’s god an honoured place. Many Vaishnava texts call Shiva the greatest devotee of Vishnu; many Shaiva texts tell stories in which Vishnu and Brahma cannot find the end of Shiva’s column of light. These stories express each community’s devotion rather than a quarrel most believers feel today.

How do their practices and symbols differ?

  • Forehead marks. Shaivas often wear three horizontal lines of holy ash (vibhuti); Vaishnavas wear a vertical mark (namam or urdhva pundra), often in a U or Y shape.
  • Sacred objects. Rudraksha beads are associated with Shiva; tulasi (holy basil) with Vishnu.
  • Mantras. The central Shaiva mantra is “Om Namah Shivaya” (see its meaning); the central Vaishnava mantras include “Om Namo Narayanaya” and “Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya”.
  • Festivals. Maha Shivaratri is the great night of Shiva; Vaikuntha Ekadashi, Rama Navami and Krishna Janmashtami are major Vaishnava festivals.

What scriptures does each tradition follow?

Both accept the Vedas and Upanishads. Beyond these, Shaivas rely on the Shaiva Agamas and Puranas such as the Shiva Purana, while Vaishnavas rely on the Pancharatra Agamas, the Vishnu Purana and above all the Bhagavata Purana. The Bhagavad Gita, spoken by Krishna, is central for Vaishnavas and read with reverence by Shaivas too.

In Tamil Nadu, each tradition has its own great body of devotional poetry. The Shaiva canon includes the Thevaram hymns of the Nayanmars and the Thirumanthiram. The Vaishnava canon is the Nalayira Divya Prabandham, the “four thousand sacred verses” of the Alvars, traditionally said to have been compiled by Nathamuni around the tenth century.

Who were the Nayanmars and the Alvars?

Between roughly the sixth and ninth centuries CE, Tamil Nadu saw a wave of devotional poetry that shaped the whole bhakti movement in India. The Nayanmars, traditionally counted as sixty-three, were devotees of Shiva. They included poets such as Appar, Sambandar and Sundarar, as well as farmers, hunters, merchants and kings, like the hunter Kannappa. The Alvars, traditionally twelve, were devotees of Vishnu, among them Nammalvar and Andal, the only woman among them.

Both groups sang in Tamil rather than Sanskrit, travelled from temple to temple, and taught that sincere love of God matters more than caste, learning or ritual. Their dates are debated by historians, but their influence on Tamil religion is not. See also bhakti yoga.

How do their philosophies differ?

Each tradition contains several schools. Among Shaivas, Shaiva Siddhanta, strong in Tamil Nadu, distinguishes God (pati), souls (pashu) and bondage (pasha), and teaches that grace frees the soul to share in Shiva’s nature. Kashmir Shaivism is non-dual: everything is Shiva’s consciousness.

Among Vaishnavas, Ramanuja’s Vishishtadvaita (“qualified non-dualism”) holds that souls and the world are real and form the body of God, while Madhva’s Dvaita holds that God and souls are eternally distinct. Later schools, such as those of Vallabha and Chaitanya, offer still other views.

So the differences are not only between the two traditions but within each of them. A Shaiva Siddhantin and a Vishishtadvaitin may in fact be closer in philosophy than a Shaiva Siddhantin and a Kashmir Shaiva.

What is Harihara?

Harihara is a form of God that is half Vishnu (Hari) and half Shiva (Hara), shown as one figure split down the middle. It expresses the idea that the two are one reality seen in two ways. In Tamil Nadu this form is worshipped as Sankaranarayanar, notably at the temple in Sankarankovil. Many temples also house both gods: at Chidambaram, for example, the shrine of Nataraja and the shrine of Govindaraja stand in the same temple complex, Govindaraja being a form of Vishnu.

The Smarta tradition, associated with Adi Shankara, worships five deities together, including Shiva and Vishnu, as forms of one Brahman. For a great many Hindu families, the choice between Shaivism and Vaishnavism is less a boundary than a matter of which form of God feels closest.

Is one better than the other?

The traditions themselves give different answers, and believers of each are devoted to their own path. From the outside, the fairest summary is that both are complete ways of devotion, with long lines of saints, deep philosophy and rich poetry. Both point the devotee toward humility, love and freedom from the ego, and both have produced people whose lives show those qualities.

Note: This article gives the general, commonly held view of the subject, drawn from traditional texts and widely shared understanding. It is not the teaching of Sivayogi. His own teaching on these matters can differ, sometimes a great deal. To hear him in his own words, read his talks.