Who Am I? The Oldest Spiritual Question Explained

By Yoga Kudil

“Who am I?” asks what you really are once your name, your body, your work and your passing thoughts are set aside. The most common answer in Indian spiritual traditions is that you are the awareness that knows the body and the mind, and not the body and mind themselves. Other traditions answer differently, and some say the question has no fixed answer at all. What they share is the view that the question is worth asking seriously, because most of our fear and restlessness rests on an idea of ourselves that we have never examined.

Why the usual answers do not hold

Ask someone who they are and you will hear a name, a family, a town, a profession, a religion. All of these are true in daily life. But each one was given to you or acquired later, and each one can change. The job will end. The body at sixty is not the body at six.

Yet through all these changes something says “I” without a break. The child said “I”, and the old person says “I”. The spiritual question is about that. What is it that has stayed while everything it called “mine” has changed?

What do the Upanishads say?

The Upanishads approach the question by elimination. The Taittiriya Upanishad describes a person as five layers, one inside the other: the body made of food, the vital breath, the mind, the intellect, and a layer of bliss. The seeker is led inward through each layer and shown that the self is subtler than all of them. The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad uses the well-known phrase “neti, neti”, meaning “not this, not this”, to set aside everything that can be pointed to as an object.

What is left is called the atman, the self that is aware of everything else. The Upanishads go further and say this self is not separate from Brahman, the reality behind the whole universe. How literally to take that statement is a matter on which the schools of Vedanta disagree.

The Tamil answer: look inside the body

The Tamil Siddhars asked the same question in a more direct and earthy way. Thirumoolar, in the Thirumanthiram, says that he once thought of the body as something flawed, and then saw the supreme reality living inside it, and so began to care for the body as a temple. In another famous verse he says, in essence, that a person who knows himself comes to no harm, and that a person ruins himself only by not knowing himself.

Sivavakkiyar is sharper. He mocks people who walk around a planted stone muttering mantras, and asks whether the stone will speak when the Lord is within. For these poets, “who am I?” is not a topic for debate. It is something to be found out in one’s own body and breath.

Does everyone agree there is a self?

No, and it is honest to say so. The Buddha taught that when you look carefully you find a body, feelings, perceptions, mental habits and consciousness, all changing, and no permanent owner behind them. In the Buddhist view, clinging to the idea of a fixed self is itself the cause of suffering.

Saiva Siddhanta, the main philosophical tradition of Tamil Saivism, takes a third position. It accepts a real, eternal soul, but holds that the soul is distinct from God and comes to know itself fully only through grace. So the same question leads to “I am Brahman” in Advaita, “there is no I to find” in Buddhism, and “I am a soul that belongs to Siva” in Saiva Siddhanta.

How do you actually ask the question?

The best-known practical method comes from Ramana Maharshi of Tiruvannamalai, who taught people to turn attention towards the sense of “I” itself instead of thinking about it. His short work is explained in our article on Who Am I? by Ramana Maharshi.

For a beginner, a simple start is enough. Sit quietly for a few minutes. Notice that you are aware of sounds, of the body, of thoughts coming and going. Then ask what is aware of all this. Do not hurry to supply an answer from a book. The value of the question lies in the looking, and a borrowed answer stops the looking. Over time the question tends to loosen the grip of the roles and worries we usually take ourselves to be, and that loosening is where self-realization is said to begin.