Advaita Meaning: The Philosophy of Not Two

By Yoga Kudil

Advaita is a Sanskrit word meaning “not two” or “non-dual”. It joins the negative prefix a to dvaita, “duality”, from dvi, “two”. As the name of a philosophy, the advaita meaning is the teaching that reality is ultimately one: the innermost self of each person, the atman, is not different from Brahman, the ground of all that exists. The school that teaches this is called Advaita Vedanta.

Why “not two” and not “one”?

The name is a negation, and that is deliberate. To say “all is one” still treats reality as a countable thing that might have been two. Advaita prefers to deny the division. The apparent gap between self and world, soul and God, knower and known is said to be a mistake of perception, and when the mistake is removed, what remains is beyond number.

The teaching is drawn from the Upanishads, especially from short statements known as the great sayings. The two most quoted are “tat tvam asi” (you are that) from the Chandogya Upanishad and “aham brahmasmi” (I am Brahman) from the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad.

Shankara and Advaita Vedanta

The philosopher most closely identified with Advaita is Adi Shankara, born according to tradition at Kaladi in Kerala. Tradition dates him to 788 to 820 CE, while many modern scholars place him somewhat earlier, in the first half of the eighth century. He wrote commentaries on the principal Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita and the Brahma Sutras.

A half-verse traditionally attributed to Shankara sums up the school: Brahman is real, the world is appearance, and the individual soul is none other than Brahman. Three ideas support it.

First, Brahman is pure being and consciousness, without parts or qualities. Second, the world of many things is experienced but is not ultimately real. Its appearance is explained by maya. Third, the individual who feels separate is in truth the atman, and the atman is Brahman. The relation between the two is explained further under atman and Brahman.

Liberation, on this view, is not gained by going anywhere or becoming anything. It is the removal of ignorance through knowledge, the path described under jnana yoga. Shankara allowed that worship and good works purify the mind, and held that knowledge alone frees.

Does Advaita deny God and the world?

This is a frequent worry. Advaita distinguishes two standpoints. From the everyday standpoint, the world is real enough, actions have results, and God as a personal Lord is rightly worshipped. From the highest standpoint, only Brahman is. Tradition credits Shankara himself with devotional hymns as well as his commentaries, and Advaita teachers do not treat devotion as a mistake.

Critics have not found this satisfactory. Ramanuja, in the eleventh and twelfth centuries, taught Vishishtadvaita, “qualified non-dualism”, in which souls and the world are real and form the body of God. Madhva, in the thirteenth century, taught Dvaita, holding that God and the soul are eternally distinct. Both objected that if the world and the individual are unreal, then devotion, ethics and even scripture lose their footing.

How Saiva Siddhanta reads the word advaita

The Tamil Saiva tradition uses the same word in a different sense. Saiva Siddhanta, set out in Meykandar’s Sivajnanabodham, traditionally dated to the thirteenth century, accepts that Siva and the soul are advaita, but explains the word as “not separate” and does not take it to mean “identical”. God, souls and the bonds that bind souls are all real and eternal. In liberation the soul is united with Siva so closely that the two cannot be told apart in experience, yet the soul does not become Siva.

This is a real disagreement with Shankara. The two schools use one word for different doctrines.

Advaita in the Tamil country

Shankara’s Advaita has nonetheless had a long life in Tamil lands. The eighteenth-century poet-saint Thayumanavar is remembered for seeking harmony between Vedanta and Siddhanta. In the twentieth century, Ramana Maharshi of Tiruvannamalai taught a direct form of non-dual enquiry based on the question “Who am I?”, and his teaching is the form of Advaita best known today.

Living with the idea

Advaita is easy to state and, by its own admission, hard to realise. Its teachers warn against merely repeating “I am Brahman” while the ego stays as it was. The classical route is to hear the teaching from a competent teacher, reflect on it until doubts are settled, and contemplate it until it becomes one’s own direct understanding.