Fate vs Free Will: What Indian Traditions Say

By Yoga Kudil

On the question of fate vs free will, most Indian traditions refuse to pick a side. Their answer is that both are real and that they are not truly opposites: fate is the result of your own past choices, and free will is the choice you are making now, which will become tomorrow’s fate.

What is meant by fate and by free will?

Fate is whatever comes to a person without being chosen: the family and body one is born with, and events that arrive whatever one’s plans. Sanskrit calls it daiva or vidhi; Tamil calls it oozh. The words are explained in destiny meaning.

Free will is the ability to choose one’s action. The Sanskrit term set against daiva is purushakara or paurusha, “human effort”; Tamil says muyarchi.

The idea that joins them is karma. In the scheme laid out in the law of karma, the portion of past action now bearing fruit is experienced as fate, while each present act is free and sows what will come later.

What does the Thirukkural say?

Thiruvalluvar states both sides with full force and leaves them standing. In the chapter on oozh he writes: what is stronger than fate? Even when one plans some other course, it gets there first (Kural 380). In the chapter on perseverance he writes: those who labour on without weariness and without delay will see even fate turn its back (Kural 620). And just before it: even if fate denies the result, effort pays the wages of one’s toil (Kural 619).

Read together, the Thirukkural teaches something practical. Fate is powerful, so do not torment yourself over outcomes. But you cannot know in advance what it holds, so work as though effort decides.

Which is stronger, according to Sanskrit texts?

They mostly lean towards effort. A well-known Sanskrit verse says that tasks are accomplished by exertion, not by wishing; deer do not walk into the mouth of a sleeping lion. A passage in the Mahabharata compares fate to a field and effort to seed, saying, in essence, that a crop needs both.

The Yoga Vasistha goes furthest. It says, in essence, that fate is nothing other than past effort, that past and present effort contend like two rams, and that the stronger prevails.

The Bhagavad Gita holds the balance. Krishna says the Lord dwells in every heart and moves all beings (18.61), yet he also says “lift yourself by yourself” (6.5), and after his whole teaching he tells Arjuna to reflect on it and then do as he wishes (18.63).

Did anyone in India teach that everything is fixed?

Yes. The Ajivikas, a sect of the Buddha’s time led by Makkhali Gosala, taught that everything is ruled by niyati, fixed destiny, and that effort changes nothing. Buddhists and Jains both argued against this, and the Buddha is recorded as counting it among the most harmful of views because it removes any reason to do good.

Ramana Maharshi’s answer

The sage Ramana Maharshi approached the question from another direction. As a young man he is recorded as having written to his mother, who wanted him to come home, that what is destined not to happen will not happen however one tries, and what is destined to happen will happen however one tries to prevent it, so the best course is to remain silent.

But when questioners later pressed him on fate and free will, his usual reply was to ask whose they are. Both, he said, belong to the ego, the sense of being a separate doer, and they last only as long as it does. Find out who it is that is bound or free, and the dispute falls away. This is the method of his teaching on the question who am I. Advaita broadly agrees: fate and free will are true at the level of the individual, not of the Self.

How to live with the question

The working rule that the traditions arrive at is this: look back with acceptance and forward with effort. Treat what has already happened as fate, since it can no longer be otherwise, and do not waste strength on regret or blame. Treat what is still to be done as free, and give it everything.