The Meaning of Life: How Different Traditions Answer

By Yoga Kudil

There is no single agreed answer to the meaning of life, and anyone who claims otherwise is speaking for one tradition. What exists is a small number of serious answers that humanity has returned to again and again. Some say meaning is given, by God or by the nature of reality, and our task is to discover it. Some say there is no given meaning and we must create it. Indian traditions mostly say that life is an opportunity: to live rightly and, finally, to be free.

How Western philosophy has answered

The ancient Greeks asked not what life means but what a good life is. Aristotle’s answer was eudaimonia, often translated as flourishing: a life of virtue and the full use of human reason.

The religions that grew from the Abrahamic root placed the meaning of life in the relationship with God: to know, love and serve the creator.

In the modern period, some philosophers concluded that the universe offers no built-in meaning. Jean-Paul Sartre argued that human beings first exist and then define themselves through their choices. Albert Camus called the gap between our longing for meaning and the world’s silence “the absurd”, and held that one can still live fully in the face of it. Viktor Frankl, a psychiatrist who survived the Nazi camps, wrote that meaning is found in work, in love, and in the stance one takes towards unavoidable suffering.

What do Indian traditions say?

Indian thought starts from a different place. It does not usually ask whether life has meaning. It asks what a human birth is for, and the classical answer is the four aims of life: dharma (right conduct), artha (livelihood and wealth), kama (enjoyment and love) and moksha (liberation). The first three make a good life in the world. The fourth is considered the highest. How these aims apply to one individual is discussed in the article on the purpose of life.

On what liberation is, the schools differ, and the differences are real:

  • Advaita Vedanta teaches that the individual Self and the absolute, Brahman, are not two. The meaning of life is to realise this directly.
  • Bhakti traditions hold that the soul is distinct from God and finds its fulfilment in loving devotion and service to him.
  • Saiva Siddhanta teaches that the soul, bound by impurity, karma and maya, matures through its births and is freed by the grace of Siva, with whom it is united without ceasing to be itself.
  • Buddhism sets aside questions about a creator or an eternal Self. Life is marked by dukkha, unsatisfactoriness, and its point is to understand the causes of suffering and end them.
  • Jainism sees life as the soul’s long work of freeing itself from karma, above all through non-violence.

The Tamil answer: live well here first

Tamil tradition has a notably grounded way of putting it. The Thirukkural is arranged around virtue, wealth and love, and says little directly about liberation. Its picture of a meaningful life is that of a householder who earns honestly, loves faithfully, welcomes guests, speaks kindly and harms no one. One of its couplets says in essence that a person who lives in this world as one ought to live will be counted among the gods.

The Siddhars and Saiva saints add an inward turn. Thirumoolar’s teaching in the Thirumanthiram that love and Siva are not two, and that only the unknowing think them separate, makes love itself the meaning.

Is the meaning of life found or made?

The gap is smaller in practice than in theory. Even those who believe meaning is given agree that each person must take it up and live it; no one can do it for you. And those who believe meaning is made rarely make it out of nothing. They find it in love, work and service, where the old traditions also point.

It may be more useful to notice when life feels meaningful than to settle the argument. For most people it is when they are absorbed in something worthwhile, when they are of use to someone, and when they are honest with themselves. The traditions would add a fourth: when the question “who is it that asks?” is taken seriously. That inquiry, who am I, is where the Indian answer finally leads.