Part 1 of 4

What Is Pulaal?

This is the first of four articles based on Sivayogi’s Tamil talk “Pulaal Maruthal” (Refusing the Senses). Watch the original talk. This article was translated from the Tamil original.

Everyone should become a human being: free, and full of celebration. That is my aim. My work is to speak as much as I can in my lifetime, to tell people how happy a human being can be, as far as it can be told, and then go.

I chose today’s topic myself: “Pulaal Maruthal”, refusing pulaal. This is not the Thirukkural chapter of that name. It is the refusing of pulaal as I speak of it.

What is pulaal?

Eye, ear, nose, mouth, skin: these are five. Taken one at a time, each is a pulan, a sense. Taken all together, their name is pulaal (a word usually read as “meat”).

People ask, “Should the feet go wherever the eye wanders?” What does that mean? The eye says something is beautiful. Did the eye really say it was beautiful, or did the mind, looking through the eye, say it was beautiful? That is the question. Was it beautiful to the eye, or to the mind? Was it the eye that looked through the eye, or the mind?

A person whose mind has not become clear becomes a slave to his senses and keeps all of them foolish. What can a fool see with his eyes? Will he look sharply? He will only say, “I don’t know this.”

Must we refuse the senses?

The eye is fine as it is; it should not be refused. The ear is fine as it is; it should not be refused. “Then why are you talking about refusing pulaal?” you will ask. What I am saying is precisely that they should not be refused.

Watch the eye with awareness. How does a sight appear to me? I opened my eyes, and the sight appears. Why does it appear? Do I reach out towards it, or does it reach out towards me? Does it appear to me because I am looking?

If you respect the senses properly, they do nothing at all when I do not want them to. What happens when I am asleep, when I am thinking of nothing? The eye does not see. The ear does not hear. The tongue and the nose are the same. How did all of them come to rest?

Because the mind came to rest. If you keep the mind at rest all the time, how will the senses be? Why not sleep without sleeping? With the eyes, the ears, everything open, with the mind kept quiet, why not simply be still?

The one who does tavam and the one who does avam

Before he even spoke about refusing pulaal, Valluvar had already said:

“Those who do tavam (austerity) do their own true work; the rest, caught in desire, do avam, what is vain.”

Refusing pulaal is for the one who does avam. What are the countless millions of people in this world doing? They are doing avam. It is they who have to refuse pulaal. For the one who does tavam, the senses are all beautiful senses.

Eye, ear and nose are the same for everyone; eyesight may differ a little from person to person. The eye shows the sight, the ear hears the sound. How are they to rest? I have this art. I have kept a place where you can be with me, stay, and spend time with me. Even if you have not practised so far, try to practise from now on. There is no use lamenting after I am gone.

I am dangerous, to those who do not live. To everyone who wants to live, who respects himself, I am special. I will not speak politely; I will speak the truth. A lie can be told in one way and then another; the truth cannot be changed.

I may criticise my guru

At this point I remember my guru, because he fought over this pulaal, over refusing the senses, and told it to society.

He did not like building an organisation, as I have. He did not come to fight society as I do. For him it was his own peace, his own happiness, and that was all, it seems. That is his business. But he is my guru. I can criticise my guru.

You may criticise me too. Some people put out videos about me, praising me or abusing me. I am happy either way. I have lived in their minds. Whether it is right or wrong comes second.

If someone says, “It was a mistake to have met such a man,” he could come and ask me directly. I have offered that chance again and again. Whatever you call wrong, I will tell you that it belongs to you, not to me. That is why he does not come.

Soap and the majority

After going to the toilet, you feel you must wash with soap; I feel plain water is enough. How can you say I am wrong? If those who wash with plain water are the majority, even the one who wanted soap will find a reason, “Why should I use chemicals?”, and switch to water. If those who use soap are the majority, even the one who said water was enough will start using soap.

You must know what you are refusing

My guru fought and said: “You talk folly, saying pulaal, pulaal.” Talking about pulaal, pulaal, is folly, it seems, foolishness.

First I need to understand what pulaal is. If someone says “refuse pulaal”, you must know what pulaal is before you refuse it. I do not even know what it is.

I do not like kichilikkai muchili. If I say this, what will you understand? You have all become sages, haven’t you; you came here and saw your guru. So you will go off too and say, “I don’t like kichilikkai muchili, because my guru doesn’t like it either.” You have decided on your own. What is kichilikkai muchili? Do you know what pulaal is?

The fattening of the flesh that Valluvar spoke of

You read Valluvar and then talk about pulaal. But if Valluvar had come before my guru, my guru would not have called him a fool, because Valluvar has a good answer:

“One who eats the flesh of another to fatten his own flesh: how can he hold on to compassion?”

Why does he say not to eat? For fattening the flesh, oon. If you eat, the body will certainly grow. But I do not eat so that my body will grow; I eat because I am hungry. If you eat thinking the flesh must grow, you keep on eating, and obesity comes. This is what Valluvar is saying: do not make eating an occupation. Eat for hunger. Valluvar is clear; he has said it very beautifully.

Does singing Thiruppugazh make the mouth fragrant?

The Thirumanthiram has also spoken of refusing pulaal. People say, “The more you sing Thiruppugazh, the more fragrant your mouth becomes.” Then you could put the toothpaste and brush aside in the bathroom and sing four Thiruppugazh songs every morning. They do not just say the mouth will not smell; they say it will be fragrant. But don’t they buy toothpaste and brushes too?

When I was twenty-seven or twenty-eight, I used to go eagerly to public debates. A man there would speak about Thiruppugazh. He had bad breath. He was a good man, but that is another matter. Does being a good man mean your mouth will not smell?

What is kichilikkai muchili?

So I must tell you what pulaal is. And you must ask, “Sir, what is kichilikkai muchili?” If you don’t ask, next week you will be going around saying, “Our master doesn’t like kichilikkai muchili.”

It is nothing: cucumber. Kichilikkai muchili is just a name I gave it. I cannot digest it, and I do not like it. You may like it. Because I do not like it, must you not like it either?

Watching and looking keenly

One who keeps close company with pulaal is called a pulaal unni, a pulaal-eater. There is another word that comes to mind with unnuthal, eating: people say “unnippaaga paar”, look closely. What does it mean to look unnippaaga? Sharply, like a knife, like the point of a pencil. Looking with your eyes whetted. Looking is one thing; looking keenly is another.

If you look at something with a conclusion already in mind, that is called looking carefully. If you look to see “Is that thing there?”, that is watching out. If you look to see “What is there?”, that is unnithal, keen looking. There is a difference between the two.

Watching to see whether a man has a knife, whether he will stab you, is caution. Looking sharply and clearly, whether he has anything or not, is keen looking.

How do the senses work?

Put jaggery on the tongue, and you taste it because it touches the tongue. When a sound is heard, the eardrum inside vibrates; that vibration turns into sound, goes inside and is understood. When a sight appears, the image falls on the eye. The nose knows a smell; where does the smell have to touch for you to know it?

We only know such things if someone teaches us; we think, “There’s no need.” But there is a need. Close your eyes and the sight disappears; close your ears and the sound goes. If you knew where in the nose a smell touches, what could you do? If you knew it touches the side of the nose, couldn’t you smear some paste over that spot?

“Science has told us.” Has science told us? If science had not told us, would the nose not smell? Where does a smell have to touch for it to come? Is the smell in the nose, or over there?

Where is the smell?

“He asks such awkward questions. We were living in peace: we smelled something, went, came back.” At meditation centres you accepted everything they told you, “It rises up, it pulls, it spins”; did anyone tell you to ask this question?

Where is the smell? “In the flower.” How did the smell that is in the flower come to my nose? “It comes when you hold it close.” If it came when held close, does it have legs and hands? Let me ask even more crudely: did it walk here, or fly?

“It comes through open space.” It does not come through open space. It comes because there is air. My breath touches the flower, and when I draw it back in, the smell comes to me. If I breathe out this way and turn to the other side, that smell will not reach me. Only if I draw back a little of the air I let out does it come to me.

Rub your nose and smell your fingers; you will get a smell. Have you ever tried it? When you have not bathed, rub your ear well and smell your fingers. Try things like this.