Part 3 of 4
What Sin Did the Eye Commit?
This is the third of four articles based on Sivayogi’s Tamil talk “Pulaal Maruthal” (Refusing the Senses). Watch the original talk. This article was translated from the Tamil original.
Is the fault in the senses, or in the mind?
You did not do your sums right; you did not do your life right either. What wrong did the eye, ear, nose or mouth do in this? Wasn’t it the mind that did wrong? And yet you call the senses wrong.
Eye, ear, nose: they are all instruments. Isn’t it enough to look at who is holding the instrument? A knife will cut an onion, and it will cut a finger too. Is the knife wrong? Isn’t the man who says “Don’t keep a knife at all” a fool? That is folly. Even a gun is wrong only when it is aimed at a human being. It was invented to protect ourselves from wild animals. Now they have said, “Don’t kill any wild animal.”
The wild boar and the electric fence
Here you cannot farm at all. Wild boars run riot in the fields and go.
That is why in the end the farmer puts up an electric fence. The boar does not die; a man dies. The poor man sows his paddy and goes out at night to keep watch. In a careless moment someone gets caught in it and dies. The current meant to kill the boar kills a man. All this happens because they said the boar must not be killed. We have made no way at all for human beings to live well.
What sin did the eye commit?
They call the senses wrong; what sin did the eye commit? It shows a sight, that is all, isn’t it? What wrong did the ear, the tongue, the nose, the skin do?
I have not gone anywhere near meat and fish; I am only talking about the senses. Because a man eats meat and fish himself, he imagines I am telling him to eat them too. Forget that meaning. I am not telling you to eat meat. If someone who has never eaten it suddenly eats it, he will not digest it. Take your tonic, take your tablets, drink your coffee.
How does sugar become white?
Do not think the sugar you put in your coffee became white by itself. Sugarcane juice is not white. Only when everything that has to be added is added does it turn white and form into crystals. Bone goes into it too. Poor people come with sacks slung over their shoulders just to gather bones; a dead dog, whatever lies in the cremation ground, they take every bone away. Bone is what they need, isn’t it? How much human bone has gone into the sugar you eat, I do not know.
If you do not know, it is not wrong. Without knowing, you will eat anything at all. Knowing is the problem. If you know it is fish, it becomes hard: “It lived in the sea, it has a mind, it has a soul.”
People say, “Eat paddy and you will be like paddy; eat a cow and you will become like a cow.” Then if you eat a human being, can you become like a human? Whatever you eat, what goes inside is vitamins and minerals; no man, goat, cow or hen goes inside.
The eye is fine, it should not be refused. The ear is fine, it should not be refused. “Then why did you talk about refusing pulaal?” What I am saying is precisely that they should not be refused.
The beam that goes out from the eye
How does a sight appear to me? Do I reach out towards it, or does it reach out towards me? It appears to me only because I am looking.
If someone looks at you, you turn that way. Not even a person: if the household dog or cat looks at you, you turn without knowing it. A beam goes out from the eye and falls on you. Keep looking at someone from behind; they will scratch themselves. Look a while longer, and they will turn round.
Who turns when you say “Hey”?
When you call someone, the sound does not merely fall on the ear; you shoot it towards them. You think a husband turns only when you call his name. In a crowd, if a wife says “Hey”, who turns? The husband.
At home there will be the mother, the wife and the children. A man shouts “You wretch!” Who gets angry? Only the one he is scolding. The word is heard only by the one it is going to.
So how are the senses? Extremely sharp. If you refuse them, you will be worse off. The whole meaning of the talk that tells you to refuse them is this: you must not turn towards wisdom, you must not live in peace, you must not be happy.
Why do you dislike seeing someone live well?
You do not like seeing anyone live well, because you are not living well. I know you are jealous of me. If you dislike looking at me, in truth you dislike yourself. If you liked yourself, you would feel, “This is how a human being ought to live.”
“If you want to live, you can live; is there no way on this earth?” Live, then. Why do you come to me and suffer?
A sad face for a hug
What is it you want? Someone should lay you in their lap and wipe your eyes. “If you are going to console me, I will keep on crying.” I need a hug from you; for that I put on a sad face. Then you have not grown up yet.
A mother told me, “My daughter scolds me harshly: ‘Don’t come and sleep next to me.’” Mother, she wants to be alone; how will she feel if you go and lie down beside her? If you went to a twenty-six-year-old boy, would he say “Come”?
When someone speaks, we notice only what they are saying; we do not know how to notice why they are saying it.
Taken in by who is speaking
When someone speaks, we look at who is speaking and believe, “If he says it, it must be right.” “This man goes to the gym; if I go to him, my body will become like his.” We strain for ten years; it turns out differently. Ask him, and he says, “You didn’t do the exercises properly.” Physiologically, it is simply not possible. He needs his business to run. Why should we be taken in by him?
Why did Valluvar tell us to refuse the senses?
The mind plays terrible tricks. Where the mind is what needs to be set right, is it fair to tell people to refuse the senses?
The reason Valluvar told us to refuse the senses is that the minds of fools had become so foolish that he decided the whole lot was a waste. Valluvar was neither a meditator nor a yogi. Perhaps he had understood God; perhaps someone had told him what God is like. What he meant to say was something else: your foolish mind has enslaved the senses, so he said, “Refuse that.”
What happens if I refuse the senses? If I said, “Valluvar has said it, so I don’t look at anyone, I don’t speak to anyone,” where would you be? If you asked a question, I would sit there like a lump of clay. Once in a while someone comes and speaks to you; what if he too must not speak? If you do not think about whether what I say is good or bad, that is your problem. But I cannot stay silent.
Who is a saanron?
A saanron is not someone who is always quiet. Saanru means an example. You think a saanron is someone old, bearded, wearing a turban and smiling. The name saanron belongs to one who sets an example. When the Kural speaks of “the mother who hears her son called a saanron”, does it mean she waited until her son grew old?
Some fellow will babble something, and you will nod, “Yes, yes.” I too should put on a jibba, wear kumkum and say: “Vegetarianism is good. A yogi is graced by eating one meal a day.” “Which meal?” “At high noon.” “But in the rainy season there is no proper noon at all, is there?”
That is why nobody asks him questions. He wrote his book and left it; you went and bought it yourselves. This is what it means to pay with your own money to have a curse put on yourself.
“Sashtiyai nokka”
“Sashtiyai nokka saravana bhavanaar sishtarukku udhavum…” Did you ask what that song means? Sashti means the sixth day: prathamai, dvitiyai, tritiyai, chaturthi, panchami, sashti. Just as people today speak English to sound modern, in those days they spoke Sanskrit. Does “sashtiyai nokka”, “looking towards the sixth”, mean you should write down the number six and stare at it?
Saram means breath, vanam means forest. Saravanam means the forest where the air is. It helps the one who bows to that. The one who wrote the song is clear; he has written it wonderfully.
If you learn it by heart, have you understood?
The eye did not understand, the ear did not understand. The mind goes on singing as though it understood. Did you understand? Did you ask anyone? You refuse even to admit that you do not know. If you learn it by heart and sing it, does that mean you know it?
How should God be worshipped?
Why do you worship God? “Everyone worships, so let us worship too.” Did you ask Him, “How should I worship you?” If someone raised his foot to salute Him, would He refuse? “He is refined,” you will say. You think He has legs, hands and eyes. For one who has nothing at all, what does it matter how you worship? Will He get angry and say, “Have you no sense?” If He had sense, would He have created you and me?
The one who sang said it clearly: “Pitthaa”, madman. How far he had understood! There is no madman in this whole world like God. “Pitthaa piraisoodee perumaane arulaalaa”: Madman, wearer of the crescent moon, great Lord, Gracious One. Couldn’t he have said “Gracious One” first and “Madman” at the end? Why did he say “Madman” right at the start? When he understood, that was the first thing that came.
How wonderful the senses are!
If you ask Murugan, “Why won’t you appear before my eyes?”, people say, “There is Murugan, there, you can see him.” Will you accept that?
How wonderful your senses are! If the eyes did not show me sights, what would I have done? Without eyes, could I have seen this world? Would I have understood anything? Now someone calls them wrong. Should we accept that? Am I wrong, or is the eye wrong?
The mind that calls itself “I” goes wrong, and then calls the eye wrong, calls the ear wrong, and says, “Refuse it.” I say: you must love your eyes, your ears, your nose, all of them. You must understand that my eyes, which can show the truth, have so far been showing lies.