Part 2 of 4
What Were the Senses Given For?
This is the second of four articles based on Sivayogi’s Tamil talk “Pulaal Maruthal” (Refusing the Senses). Watch the original talk. This article was translated from the Tamil original.
Smell comes only when you draw in air
What do you do when you smell something? You hold it near your nose and draw in air. Draw in, and the smell comes; close your nose, and it does not. Smell comes only when it is mixed in the air. Because breath is always going in and coming out, He did not make a separate path for smell; He brings it along with the air.
When there is a stink you close your nose, turn your face away, hold up a handkerchief. You did all this because you knew, didn’t you? But if someone asks, you say, “I don’t know.” You know; you just don’t know that you know. That is the problem.
Pulaal means the five senses
Eye, ear, nose, mouth, skin: taken one at a time, each is a pulan, a sense; taken all together, they are pulaal. What does “Should the feet go wherever the eye wanders?” mean?
The eye says “beautiful”. Did the eye say it was beautiful, or did the mind looking through the eye say so? It was the mind that looked through the eye. It was beautiful to the mind. The sweetness of a song, a taste, a fragrance are the same: they are not for the ear or the tongue or the nose, but for the mind.
For the nose alone, the name was given directly. It is the mind, manam, that senses the smell; so smell is called manam, fragrance.
Three loops and two loops
A man called Pavanandhi Munivar came along and fooled us by separating the “three-loop” ண from the “two-loop” ன, the two letters for n. When spoken, manam the fragrance and manam the mind sound alike to the listener, just like kal (stone) and kal (toddy). The meaning is understood only from the context: if you say “I drank kal”, it is not the solid one; if you say “I sat on a kal”, it is not the liquid one. They changed the letters and created confusion. But what the nose does is direct; so it was named directly: manam.
The mind rules the senses
Pulaal means all of them together. Why must they be spoken of together? Seeing through the eye is the mind, hearing through the ear is the mind, sensing smell through the nose, taste through the tongue and touch through the skin is the mind. It is the mind that rules all these senses.
Taught what is beautiful
What did I call beautiful? I was taught: fair, with a reddish skin, is beautiful. Would you say your mother is not beautiful? How did she look beautiful to you? If you had been born with this knowledge, you would not have accepted even your own mother.
Once grown up, you say, “Mother knows nothing, Father is a village man.” If the father pulls a rickshaw, there are those who say, “He works at our house.” Why? A person becomes whatever he is taught, sees only that through his eyes, and does not see the rest at all. A sight should be seen only as a sight, not read. Because I know how to read, I could not see it as a sight.
Must you know how to read, or must your eyes see?
Someone translates my messages into Hindi and puts them in the video description. There is a line drawn on top, and below it, loop after loop, as if someone had squeezed out a jangiri. To one who knows that language, it calls up a sound; to us it does not. Is the sight at fault for that?
Must you know how to read, or must your eyes see? If you cannot read, are your eyes useless? Valluvar says:
Those with learning are the ones said to have eyes; the unlearned have only two sores on their face.
If you learn Hindi, are you learned? Who are the learned?
He taught that pulaal means meat
When I heard the word pulaal, I did not understand it at all. Someone just said, “Mutton, beef, chicken: that is pulaal.”
Only I know where I took the word kichilikkai from; I have my own reason for it. But in your case, someone simply taught you the reason: pulaal means meat. Now whatever verse you read, you fit that meaning onto it.
When it says “refusing pulaal”, what was refused? Why does he mention both oon and pulaal? Someone says “oon, pulaal, nerve”. Pulaal appears in the Thirumanthiram and the Thiruvasagam; the word pulaiyar appears too.
Someone you know neither in front nor behind
A person whose mind has not become clear becomes a slave to his senses and stands there keeping them foolish. His eyes can see, he looks; still he will say, “I don’t know.”
If someone asks me, “Do you know him from in front or behind?”, meaning “Do you know him at all?”, I will say, “If I go in front and look, I’ll know him from in front; if I go behind and look, I’ll know him from behind.” Only a blind man has people he does not know. When my eyes can see, who is there that I do not know?
“I can’t understand what he says,” you say. Can’t you understand from the situation? In a vast desert, someone asks for something in some language. I have a can of water in my hand. Do I need to know the language to understand what he is asking?
People sing, “For twenty years I was in my parents’ keeping; in twenty seconds I became yours.” Did that happen through language? “A single glance is enough; are thousands of words needed?” Animals communicate without language.
The language the dog spoke
A video. A child shoots at a dog with a toy gun; it falls down. It shoots another; that one falls too. The third falls as well. Only the next dog does not fall. Then another dog gives it a tap. The child shoots again, and now that one falls too. Everyone was laughing. What language did that dog speak?
Even in a language you do not know, you can tell whether it is joy, sorrow or anger. If someone scolds you with a smile, you will not get angry. Only if you understand this can you live. Only then can you sing, “I saw every drama in your dancing eyes.”
Right now the senses have made the mind a slave. Your wonderful eyes, you have set them to search for and grope after only what you already know.
Are there only six tastes?
Does the tongue sense only six tastes? Rock sugar, sugar, jaggery, honey: all are sweet. If they are all one, then how, even when you lick them blindfolded, can you tell them apart: this is honey, this is jaggery, this is rock sugar, this is palm jaggery? Then sweetness is not one thing.
In a single line, “Talking pulaal, pulaal is folly”, my guru struck everyone down and went his way.
So many kinds for sweetness alone. Is the heat of dried chilli, the heat of green chilli and the heat of biting into pepper all the same? How did you tell each one apart? Where were you fooled? All that is left is to sing, “Who is such a gullible simpleton as I?”
What were the senses given for?
I am one who has already been fooled. My senses are waiting to show me rightly, wondering whether this fellow will ever realise the truth.
Why did God give us eyes? To see what I have learned, or to see and learn? Ears? To hear what I expect, or to learn from what I hear? The tongue? To sense taste, or to check whether the taste I was told about is there? The nose? To sense one smell, or to understand the differences between smells?
You say perfectly well: this is iruvatchi, this is rose, this is jasmine, this is excrement. There are people who say, “My daughter can tell from the smell alone whether there is too much salt or too little.” Our organs are that subtle, that complete.
Right now the mind has gone bad. People whose minds have gone bad say, “Suppress the senses; give up your eyes, give up your ears.” I say: use the eyes, ears and nose you have rightly. My guru, too, said just that before he left.
Five cows that wander grazing
Thirumoolar calls the senses five cows that wander about grazing. We ask, “Is your eye grazing?”, don’t we? That is it. Men’s eyes graze; that is why women do not go out without a dupatta. In a Rajini song he says, “The face is up here.” Even if you lift the head and hold it there, the gaze slips down.
A dog, a cat, a lion, a tiger will all look into your eyes when they communicate. Only man looks everywhere he can except the eyes: “Is she wearing a lot of necklaces? Does she have bangles? Is she well off?” To whom are the senses enslaved now?
Rain that falls when she says “fall”
It is the slave of the mind who says, “Don’t listen to what the senses say.” He is a fool; he neither has eyes nor is he learned. First of all, he made deivam, a deity, and kadavul, God, one and the same. Valluvar says:
She who does not worship a god, but rises worshipping her husband: she says “rain”, and the rain falls.
He explained “does not worship a god” as meaning a woman who does not pray to God, like a man of the Dravidar Kazhagam, the anti-religious party: “Don’t worship God, respect only your husband; then if you say ‘fall’, the rain will fall.”
“Rain that falls when she says fall” does not mean rain that falls at her command. When a farmer has ploughed his field and thinks how good it would be if it rained, how happy will he be if the rain falls just then? She is that kind of woman: one who fulfils what you hope for. But you take your wife off to the desert and say, “You are one who worships me; say ‘fall’ and let the rain fall!” What man does!
Refusing pulaal is not refusing meat
So, not eating meat, fish and eggs is not refusing pulaal at all, not in the least. They have been fooling you by saying so. If someone fools you, whose fault is it? The fault of the one who was fooled.
The 8% interest swindle
“Give me one lakh; I’ll pay you 8% interest a month, and you can get ahead in life.” So I took one lakh from a man. I paid him 8,000 a month, out of his own money. After I had paid for ten months, he told ten people. They gave me a lakh each, ten lakhs in all; and they keep telling others, and others keep giving. I became a millionaire, rolled it all up and left. Everyone reckons only “We gave one lakh.” In truth, who got his one lakh back?
Now, are they wrong, or am I? There are many of them; if I am right, that is one vote; if you are right, how many votes? When you handed over the lakh, did all of you go together and hand it over? You gave it separately, didn’t you? Now you all stand together on the road and protest. Four policemen can beat me; but with lakhs of you, even forty thousand policemen could not beat you. When fools number in the lakhs, they change justice itself. When will this world come to its senses?
If someone says, “Give me one lakh and I’ll pay you 8,000 a month,” shouldn’t you say, “In that case keep it yourself and be happy”? Shouldn’t you ask where he will bring it from to pay you?